N’weti’s Community Scorecard Experience in Nampula: a Case Study

This case study was commissioned by N’weti Comunicação para a Saúde to explore the changes emerging from the implementation of an adapted version of the Community Scorecard (CSC) tool in 11 health facilities catchment areas in Nampula. This case study discusses how N’weti has adapted the Community Scorecard (CSC) tool to better improve the quality of the participation and prospects of accountability for citizens. The case study presents evidence that the adapted CSC tool has resulted in an increased awareness of rights, an improved relationship with the service providers, a revitalisation of the health unit Co-management Committees, citizens feeling that their voice is being heard, and N’weti is recognised by people and authorities as catalyser and legitimate mediator of this voice. However, challenges also surfaced which N’weti must reflect and learn from. The first relates to the meaningful control from regular citizens (rather than NGO staff members) of the institutionalisation, follow-up of commitments and advocacy actions derived from the implementation of a CSC process. Other challenges refer to social exclusion, the lack of a deeper understanding of power dynamics, and the fact that ignoring previous histories of citizen engagement and other contextual factors can be misleading as not all change can be directly attributed to the implementation of the CSC.